Monday, September 14, 2009

What's Right with Buy-and-Hold?

So Buy-and-Hold has its flaws, but the alternative, which is trading is not much better. Empirically, trading has not help generated wealth. But before we come to some conclusion, let's look at the usual Pros with regard to Buy-and-Hold.


1. Missing out the 10 biggest days in positive movement

Studies have shown that if you subtract the returns of the 10 biggest positive gain days in the past 20 yrs, your long term average annual return drops something like from 8%pa to 4%pa. This is major bcos suddenly you might as well go and buy 30 Yr Singapore Govt bonds and that could have given you close to 4%pa, without all the risks associated with stock market. Since we cannot predict which days will be the biggest positive gain days in advance, value investors argue that we should always buy and hold to reap the full benefits.

2. Transaction cost

This has come down over the years but still constitute 0.5% or more to most retail investors. Considering in Singapore where the minimal brokerage cost is S$20 per trade, you need to do a S$8,000 trade so that you can get the buy and sell costs to be 0.5% of your trade. Sadly it can only go as low as 0.25% bcos after that, the brokers charge based on the size of your trade. So let's work with 0.5%. Most retail investors would probably do more than 1 buy-sell trade per year, let's say they do 2. We know that average annual market return is 8% and two trade incur transaction costs of 1%. Congrats, you just gave your brokers a 12% commission. Every year. So Buy-and-Hold pls, save the transaction cost.

3. Dividends

Globally dividend yield usually ranges from 2-4% and in extreme times, you see dividend yield of a market going to 6-7%, like the STI in 2008. Albeit it's a lagging yield bcos the data is always late to factor in a drop in dividend going forward. Anyhow, the point is, dividend is a huge part of return. Since we all know that average market return for investment is only 8%, dividends can constitute 25-50% of this market return. It does make sense to focus a lot on dividend stocks. And needless to say, to get dividends, you can't just trade, you need to buy-and-hold.

4. Missing out the full growth

This will be the most compelling argument. Trust me.

If you have bought a Great Company, not just Good but Great with a capital G, then there is never a right time to sell bcos the company simply grows exponentially and overwhelms everything! Some of Berkshire's companies would illustrate this very well. I will just highlight See's Candy and Coke. Buffett bought over the whole of See's Candy for USD 25mn in 1972. Today See's generate pre-tax earnings of over USD 1bn, if See's is a listed co. the market cap would be close to USD 20bn. So that's close to a 1,000 fold return. Mind you, that's 100,000% return. If you sold for 100% profit in 1973, you just made the biggest mistake of your life.

Coke tells the same story. Berkshire bought 8% of Coke for USD 1bn in 1988, today the same stake is worth USD 10bn and Coke's pre-tax earnings is USD 7bn, of which Berkshire is entitled USD 600mn (on paper). In another 10 yrs, the profits entitled to Berkshire would be more than what Berkshire paid for and this current ten bagger will become a 20 bagger or even more. So is there ever a right time to sell Coke?

Sadly, most retail investors never get to enjoy this kind of thrill bcos a 20% profit in 2 weeks is already better than sex.


Again in investing, there are no hard and fast rules, most of the time buy-and-hold makes sense, but there are times that they do not, some times you can take some profit here and there during those periods. However, to trade in and out every few weeks or days and try to beat buy-and-hold is a tall order. Much taller than most people would like to think so. Not to mention the effort needed to do those weekly trades! So run through the pros and cons again, when you are tempted to trade!


  1. Welcome to my Website

    I am a trading representative from Lim & Tan Securities.

    Established in 1973, Lim & Tan Securities is a leading securities brokerage firm in Singapore with a strong focus in retail market. Believing in providing cutting-edge technology to its clients, it was amongst the first to introduce Internet Share Trading.

    With its extensive network and market insights, it is able to provide you with in-depth research on local and key global securities markets.





    Interested in trading in shares? Call me today.

    Earn LinkPoints when you trade with!

    Receive 6000 LinkPoints when you open a Online trading account and complete 3 Online trades within 3 months from account opened.

    In addition, Link cardholders will be awarded 5 LinkPoints for every $1 of commission paid with

    Free 1 month subscription of 'The Edge Singapore' financial weekly magazine when you sign up as a new client.

    > Click here to find out more
    > Start trading with Lim & Tan Securities

    > Click here to contact me now

    Contact Me

    Mail Lim & Tan Securities Pte Ltd
    20 Cecil Street
    #09-00 Equity Plaza
    Singapore 049705
    Attn: Roger Pay

    Phone +65 98527793, Helpdesk +65 67998180

    Fax +65 6538 7730


    I look forward to your feedback. You can call me at +65 9852 7793, if you have queries.

    You can also email me at with your questions or feedback.

  2. I feel any advertisement or marketing should be removed to make this blog more "valuable".


  3. I believe best to do both buy-and-hold as well as trade. If you are lucky to buy on a major dip, buy and hold till market starts dropping into the next recession - then get out fast.
    In between, some of the spare cash could be used for trades - for the fun and potentially to get better returns that what you can get if you try buy-and-hold when market is no longer at the bottom.

  4. Hi :)

    I wonder if anyone did a study on what happens if you miss out on the 10 biggest days in negative movement. Would your portfolio returns be much higher?

    We also can't predict which days will be the biggest negative days in advance, so the first point can in fact be a con, not only a pro.

  5. hmmm, that's an interesting notion.

    But you can't actually miss out the 10 biggest -ve days. In order to miss them out, you have to sell before those days and buy back the next day. If someone could have done that, then perhaps they wouldn`t have missed out the 10 +ve days.

    In that case, they possess some kind of skill that would definitely beat buy and hold, and they shouldnt be buying and holding but trade their way to riches...

    Just thinking out loud, not sure if this makes sense...